EU Law Radar

Monitoring References to the Court of Justice of the European Union

Case C-837/26, Airwair International – yellow stitching and the forms of a shoe

C-837/26pendingCURIA ↗EUR-Lex ↗

A trade mark can be registered for footwear as a whole, while the public knows the sign only on a particular kind of boot. The Benelux Court of Justice asks what follows when the mark is challenged.

Facts

Airwair International Ltd, the company behind the Dr. Martens brand, and Van Haren Schoenen BV are in proceedings before the Benelux Gerechtshof (Benelux Court of Justice). According to published reports of the earlier stages, Van Haren applied to the Benelux Office for Intellectual Property to invalidate Airwair’s position mark for yellow stitching on the welt between the upper and the sole. The Office rejected the application in 2022, finding that the mark had acquired distinctive character through use, and Van Haren appealed. The mark is registered for a category of goods that includes different forms of footwear. The Benelux Court asks whether acquired distinctiveness must be shown for all of those forms or only some, and whether, if the ground for invalidity concerns only some forms, the mark must be invalidated only in part.

Questions Referred

1. Is Article 4(4) of the Trade Marks Directive to be interpreted as meaning that a position mark such as that at issue here can acquire distinctive character through use only if this has been demonstrated in respect of all forms of the goods in the category of goods for which the trade mark is registered, or is it sufficient for this to have been demonstrated in respect of some of those forms?

2. Is Article 7 of the Trade Marks Directive to be interpreted as meaning that partial invalidation of a trade mark must also apply where there are different forms of the goods in the category of goods for which a position mark such as that at issue here is registered, and the ground for invalidity concerns only some of those forms?

Comment

Article 4(4) of Directive (EU) 2015/2436 saves a mark that lacks inherent distinctiveness if, “following the use which has been made of it, it has acquired a distinctive character”, including against an application for a declaration of invalidity. A position mark is a sign defined by where it sits on the product. Its distinctiveness depends on how consumers see that place on the goods. Yellow stitching on the welt of a lace-up boot is one thing; the same stitching on a sandal, a loafer or a children’s shoe may not be recognised at all. The first question asks whether the proprietor must prove recognition across every form of footwear covered by the registration, or whether proof for the forms on which the mark is actually known is enough.

The second question supplies the alternative. Article 7 provides that where a ground for invalidity exists “in respect of only some of the goods or services”, the invalidity “shall cover those goods or services only”. The Benelux Court asks whether that rule can operate on forms of goods within a single category, so that the mark survives for boots and falls for the rest. The Court of Justice has divided registered categories before. In Ferrari (C‑720/18 and C‑721/18), on genuine use, it held that use for some goods in a category counts for the whole category “unless it is apparent … that a consumer who wishes to purchase those goods will perceive them as an independent subcategory”. A similar test of how consumers divide the category may decide this case. The answer will matter beyond footwear, wherever a shape or position mark is registered for a broad category but known on only part of it.

Sources

OJ notice C/2026/5882 (EUR‑Lex) · Case file on CURIA · Directive (EU) 2015/2436 · Ferrari, C‑720/18 and C‑721/18 (ECLI:EU:C:2020:854)