EU Law Radar

Monitoring References to the Court of Justice of the European Union

Tag

validity

28 case reports

Case C-837/26, Airwair International – yellow stitching and the forms of a shoe

Dr. Martens' owner holds a Benelux position mark for the yellow stitching where the upper meets the sole. A Dutch shoe company seeks to invalidate it. The Benelux Court of Justice asks whether acquired distinctiveness must be shown for every form of footwear the mark covers, and whether a mark can be partly invalidated by form of goods rather than by category.

Case C-1028/26, Gradijk – the Migration Pact and a narrower appeal against transfer

The Asylum and Migration Management Regulation, in force since 1 July 2026, limits what an asylum seeker may argue against a transfer to another Member State to three grounds. Within weeks, a Dutch court asked the Court of Justice in two cases whether that limit is valid under Article 47 of the Charter, and how the best interests of children fit into the review.

Case C-760/26, Association belgo-palestinienne – may a Member State block transit to prevent genocide?

The Dual-Use Regulation lets a Member State stop goods in transit only where they may serve weapons of mass destruction or a military end-use in a country under an arms embargo. Belgian NGOs say the Genocide Convention and the Geneva Conventions oblige Belgium to do more. The Brussels Court of Appeal asks whether the Regulation is valid and whether Article 351 TFEU lets Belgium act anyway.

Case C-614/26, Irish Pharmaceutical Healthcare Association – who pays to take medicines out of wastewater

The recast Urban Wastewater Treatment Directive makes producers of medicines and cosmetics pay at least 80% of the cost of removing micropollutants from wastewater. The industry's direct actions were dismissed as inadmissible; the Irish High Court has now sent the validity question to Luxembourg, and in Poland's parallel action Advocate General Kokott has proposed that the core of the scheme be annulled.

Case C-838/26, Sconto – OLAF in Taiwan, and the report no one can check

A Czech customs dispute over suspected imports of Chinese-origin goods turns on two OLAF missions to Taiwan, in 2013 and 2014. The Czech Supreme Administrative Court asks whether OLAF had a legal basis to investigate there, whether its reports are valid, and how much they can prove when their content cannot be verified.

Case C-530/15, Melitta France – card core, hardcore packaging law

Inside a roll of toilet paper is a cardboard core. Does this internal element form part of the toilet paper’s packaging? It is a question which has stymied the French courts. The answer depends on the word ‘packaging’ which is … Continue reading →