Case T-66/25, Meta Platforms v Commission – the Marketplace fine and the rivals' ad data
The Commission’s Marketplace fine against Meta rests on two theories: that Marketplace was forced on every Facebook user, and that competitors paying Meta for advertising were made to hand over their data. Meta contests both.
Facts
By decision C(2024) 8053 final of 14 November 2024 in Case AT.40684 – Facebook Marketplace, the Commission found that Meta had infringed Article 102 TFEU and Article 54 of the EEA Agreement. It fined Meta €797.72 million. According to the Commission’s announcement, Meta had tied its online classified ads service, Facebook Marketplace, to the Facebook social network, so that Facebook users were automatically exposed to Marketplace. It had also imposed unfair trading conditions on rival classified ads services that advertise on Facebook or Instagram, whose terms allowed Meta to use ad-related data generated by those competitors for the benefit of Marketplace. The Commission ordered Meta to bring the conduct to an end. Meta Platforms and Meta Platforms Ireland brought an action for annulment on 28 January 2025. They ask the General Court to annul the decision, in the alternative to annul specific articles of it, and in the further alternative to annul or substantially reduce the fine.
Pleas in Law
According to the Official Journal notice, the applicants rely on seven pleas in law:
1. First plea in law, alleging the contested decision errs in its findings of market definition and dominance.
2. Second plea in law, alleging the contested decision errs in finding that the applicants’ conduct constitutes abusive ‘tying’.
3. Third plea in law, alleging the contested decision errs in finding that the applicants’ alleged ‘tying’ conduct is capable of foreclosing competition.
4. Fourth plea in law, alleging the contested decision errs in concluding that the applicants’ alleged ‘tying’ conduct was not objectively justified.
5. Fifth plea in law, alleging the contested decision errs in finding that the applicants have imposed abusive unfair trading conditions.
6. Sixth plea in law, alleging the contested decision errs in establishing the level of the fine.
7. Seventh plea in law, alleging the contested decision errs in setting out the specific remedies the applicants should implement.
Sources
Comment
The tying theory has an unusual shape. In classic tying cases a customer who wants the main product has to take the second one too. Facebook is free, and nobody has to buy Marketplace. The Commission’s case is that exposure is the tie: every Facebook user sees Marketplace, which gives it a distribution advantage that rivals cannot match. Meta’s answer, as it put it when the fine was announced, is that users can choose whether to engage with Marketplace and many do not. The second and third pleas therefore turn on whether placing a free service in front of a captive audience is “tying” at all, and whether it is capable of foreclosing competitors who sell classified ads by other means.
The fifth plea concerns the part of the decision with the widest reach. Rival classified ads services were also Meta’s advertising customers. The decision found that the terms on which they bought ads let Meta use the data their campaigns generated to the benefit of its own competing service. If the General Court upholds that finding, it will confirm that a dominant platform’s terms of service for business customers can be an abuse in themselves when they turn a competitor’s data into an input for the platform’s own offer. The Digital Markets Act now addresses such data use by gatekeepers directly, in Article 6(2).
The case is one of several between Meta and the Commission now before the EU courts, including Meta’s action against the interim measures on WhatsApp and rival AI assistants, T‑521/26. The General Court has not yet given judgment in this one.